Skip to content
SIB

All games

The Case of the Golden Idol cover

Is The Case of the Golden Idol worth it?

Read reviews

Is The Case of the Golden Idol worth it in 2026?

SIB verdict: Buy

Buy

Nothing on this card can be bought.

Recent Steam reviews are 96.1% positive over 30 days, up 1 point on the previous 90 days.

The Case of the Golden Idol is steady. 96.1% positive in the last 30 days, against 94.5% over 90 days.

The Case of the Golden Idol summary

Buy — clever, scene-by-scene deduction with satisfying puzzle design and entwined narrative reward persistent players. Buy because reviews praise its challenging investigations, engaging lore and rewarding eureka moments that make the playtime worthwhile.

The Case of the Golden Idol pros and cons

Pros

  • Engaging, scene-by-scene deductive puzzle design.
  • Narrative and puzzles are tightly interwoven.
  • Multiple satisfying eureka moments for players.

Cons

  • Some puzzles are obtuse or frustrating at times.
  • Hints system gated in an annoying way for some.
  • Replayability limitations noted by players.

Great if you like methodical detective puzzles and lore.

Skip if you want lots of replayability or easy handholding.

AI summary of Steam player reviews · updated

The verdict comes from our rules, not AI → How it works

Where to buy

Steam, plus partner stores where a link has been added.

What players think

AI summary of Steam player reviews

  • Gameplay

    Positive

    Deductive puzzles praised as challenging and rewarding.

  • Story

    Positive

    Overarching plot slowly revealed and praised for lore.

  • Graphics

    Positive

    Art style initially divisive but ultimately appreciated.

  • Value

    Mixed

    Some find replay limitations and hint gating frustrating.

  • Length

    Positive

    Short, focused runtime fits well with puzzle design.

At a glance

Release
13 Oct 2022
Developer
Color Gray Games
Publisher
Playstack
Price
£16.99
Modes
Single player

A new kind of detective game that allows you to think and investigate freely. Discover clues surrounding 12 strange and gruesome deaths and build your own theory. Pick your suspect, deduce the motive, unmask the awful truth.

Gear for this game

How long is it?

Main story
6.2 hrs
Main + extras
7 hrs
Completionist
10.8 hrs

Trend

Player sentiment is from Steam (PC) reviews.

All time

97.8%

11,016 reviews

12 months

95.5%

1,740 reviews

90 days

94.5%

384 reviews

30 days

96.1%

51 reviews

Stable+1 pts versus the previous 90 days

050100

Bars are review volume. The line is the positive percentage. Periods under 10 reviews are faded.

The Case of the Golden Idol reviews

Read reviews

Not enough reviews yet

Community vote

SIB verdict: Buy (from 11,016 Steam reviews)

Community: 0 / 20 votes. Results unlock at 20

Separate from the SIB verdict. Votes never change a score, a ranking, or a collection.

Sign in to vote

Reviews

Separate from the SIB verdict

Be the first to review

    Write a reviewSign in to write a review.

    Similar games

    Method

    Reviews read
    899
    Kept
    757
    Excluded
    142
    History window
    2022-10-01 to 2026-11-16
    • Under 60 minutes played at review: 7
    • Under 20 characters of text: 131
    • Received for free: 4

    Data from Steam. SIB is not affiliated with Valve Corporation. Genre and platform information from IGDB. IGDB record

    Last updated

    Read the full method